Buckle up, dynasty degenerates—with the 2025 NFL Draft just weeks away, we’re already peering over the horizon to our Way-Too-Early 2026 Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft.
The confetti’s been swept up from Ohio State’s latest scarlet-and-gray shower and our 2025 Dynasty Rookie Rankings & SuperFlex Big Board, and Post-Combine Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft are must-read before the NFL Draft. This year’s rookie RBs look like a cheat code, but don’t sleep on the future: 2026 has some talent, led by Arch Manning and Nico Iamaleava at quarterback and Jeremiyah Love and Nick Singleton running back, making those positions worth hoarding picks for.
We’re not gazing at a mythical beast like Saquon Barkley, Bijan Robinson, or Ashton Jeanty quite yet—patience, though, because the top two running backs are simmering, ready to boil over. Plus, don’t sleep on those late-bloomers like we’ve had with Joe Burrow, Jayden Daniels, and Cam Ward, who were late to the party in the past.
Peeking this far ahead is like trying to predict the weather. Some of these first-round hopefuls will soar, others will chase NIL cash back to campus, and a few might trip over themselves in their final college spin.
Still, we’re diving headfirst into the chaos with our Way-Too-Early 2026 Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft. Let’s see who’s got the juice to make your future roster a contender.
Note: This mock draft is based on a 12-team SuperFlex dynasty league with half-PPR settings and spotlights the eligible players for the 2026 NFL Draft.
2026 DYNASTY ROOKIE MOCK DRAFT
1.01: ARCH MANNING, QB TEXAS
Arch Manning is strutting into his first year as Texas’ starting quarterback with the city of Austin on his shoulders. Last season, he was the human equivalent of a hype button: trotting onto the field in obvious running situations, sending the Longhorn faithful into a frenzy, and usually bulldozing his way to a fresh set of downs.
Don’t be fooled, though—he has all the tools. With a rocket arm and a pedigree dripping with NFL Hall of Fame DNA, Arch can fling it, all while boasting a football IQ that suggests he’s been decoding defenses since diapers.
The sample size is slim, but his Mississippi State torching, with Quinn Ewers out of action, proved he’s a dual-threat menace. He has the deep-ball accuracy to stretch defenses thin and the legs to turn busted plays into big gains. A quick release, sharp anticipation, and a skill set tailor-made for modern NFL schemes? Check, check, check.
Manning already has NFL GMs drooling, pegged as the slam-dunk No. 1 pick whenever he decides to ditch college—and he’s eligible now, as the 1.01 of this class. He’s a franchise-flipping phenom who could strut into a pro huddle Day 1, though Texas might dangle a juicier NIL deal to keep their golden boy for one more lap.
Oh, and his first gig as the guy? A little road trip to Columbus for a rematch with the reigning national champs.
1.02: JEREMIYAH LOVE, RB NOTRE DAME
Jeremiyah Love is the kind of freak-show athlete who looks like he could’ve wandered off an Olympic track and onto a football field just to mess with people. Whether he’s blazing past defenders on a 98-yard sprint to kick off the College Football Playoff or hurdling would-be tacklers, this dude’s a specimen screaming to take over your dynasty roster.
Love’s elite speed and Swiss-Army-knife versatility—1,362 total yards and 19 touchdowns in a starring role last year—make him a drool-worthy prospect for NFL scouts and fantasy nerds alike that would’ve likely ranked him RB2 if he were eligible for the loaded 2025 class.
Heading into his second season as Notre Dame’s bell cow, he’s poised to be a dynamic, game-wrecking weapon. Love’s outlook is extremely bright in a modern NFL offense that craves explosive playmakers who can do it all.
1.03: NICK SINGLETON, RB PENN STATE
Penn State’s been stuck watching their B1G bullies flex championship hardware for two straight years. But, now they’re reloading with a vengeance, and Nick Singleton’s ready to bulldoze his way into a top dynasty pick.
With Drew Allar slinging it (we’ll get to him later) and a nasty two-headed backfield beast alongside Kaytron Allen, the Nittany Lions’ offense is primed for a big season. Singleton and Allen complement each other perfectly, similarly to TreVeyon Henderson and Quinshon Judkins, with Singleton being the future NFL workhorse.
This dude’s NFL projection screams three-down stud upside right out of the gate. His vision, power, and burst combo make him a top prospect, slicing through defenses with one-cut precision. He’s flashed some receiving chops too, and if he polishes that, he could morph into an every-down nightmare.
In the right landing spot, Singleton’s pass-pro savvy and improving hands could snag him third-down duties early. With excellent production, raw tools, and a ceiling still climbing, Singleton currently sits above the rest of the quarterbacks after Manning comes off the board.
1.04: NICO IAMALEAVA, QB TENNESSEE
Nico Iamaleava strolled onto Tennessee’s campus as a top-ranked recruit in the land, lugging heavy expectations. And so far, he’s delivered.
As a true sophomore, he dragged the Vols to a CFP berth, strutting his stuff as one of the SEC’s elite QBs. At a spindly 6-foot-6 frame begging for more muscle, he erupted this year, slinging 19 touchdowns against just five picks while galloping for 360 yards on the ground.
Scouts are drooling over his raw talent, think plus-arm strength and legs to move the chains, but he still has some growing pains to iron out as a young quarterback.
Picture him in a new-age, creative offense that lets him use his arm talent and legs: lethal. He proved his grit against the Buckeyes in the playoffs, literally cracking his helmet on a hit, then shrugging it off with 20 gritty carries. Nico’s ceiling is extremely high with time to bulk up and tweak his mechanics as he enters another season in Knoxville.
1.05: LANORRIS SELLERS, QB SOUTH CAROLINA
LaNorris Sellers went from a “who’s that?” blip on the radar to college football’s human highlight reel.
In his first spin as South Carolina’s starter, he turned heads and torched turf, piloting the Gamecocks to a 9-3 record with a crazy dual-threat stat line: 65.6% completion percentage, 2,534 passing yards, 18 touchdowns, plus 674 rushing yards and seven scores—highlighted by a 75-yard touchdown against LSU and a 166-yard ground clinic through Dabo’s soul.
At 6-foot-3 and 245 lbs, Sellers is like a souped-up Jalen Hurts with a thicker frame, beefier arms, and athleticism that leaps off the screen. He’s a unicorn who can bulldoze linebackers and zip passes with the best of ‘em.
But here’s the catch: he’s still green, with just one starting season under his belt, and his pocket presence and touch passes need some help. Scouts are drooling over his sky-high ceiling, but with that rawness, another year of college seasoning might be the smart play. Sellers is the ultimate dynasty gamble. He’s a potential franchise cornerstone dripping with upside, ready to either light up the league or keep you guessing like Anthony Richardson.
1.06: JORDYN TYSON, WR ARIZONA STATE
Time to pump the brakes on the QB frenzy. Jordyn Tyson, Arizona State’s ankle-snapping wideout, is my first wideout off the board.
Standing at 6-foot-1, 190 lbs, he first turned heads as a true freshman at Colorado, topping the Buffs in receiving yards before bolting to ASU. In 2024, he didn’t just break out, he dominated, snagging 75 balls for 1,101 yards and 10 touchdowns, earning third-team All-American honors and the Big 12 Offensive Newcomer of the Year crown as Sam Leavitt’s alpha.
A late-November injury against rival Arizona sidelined him for what should’ve been his national breakout party during the CFP, but not before he racked up five 100-yard games and cemented his spot as my WR1 in a thin wideout class.
Coached by NFL icon Hines Ward, Tyson is morphing into a do-it-all menace as the complete package. His tape screams “pro-ready,” shaking corners and blocking his ass off.
Yeah, it looks like a down year for receivers, but with a full season ahead for others to catch up, Tyson’s sitting pretty atop the heap.
1.07: DREW ALLAR, QB PENN STATE
Drew Allar’s tenure in Happy Valley has been a wild ride. One minute, he’s flashing QB1 vibes with a howitzer arm and sharp decision-making, the next he’s chucking a season-ending pick against Notre Dame in the CFP semis. Oh, and he didn’t even complete a pass to a wideout in that game—talk about a shit show.
Still, Allar has leveled up each year, and with Penn State gearing up for a monster 2025, Allar’s got the keys to a souped-up offense.
James Franklin gifted Allar two legit portal receivers to replace the do-it-all TE Tyler Warren, while the nation’s nastiest RB duo will set the table. At 6’5” and 240 lbs, Allar’s built like an NFL prototype, thriving in a vertical system that lets his cannon arm sling downfield and his athleticism shine outside the pocket.
Top-10 pick buzz for 2026? You bet. Especially if he balls out against Oregon and Ohio State. Overall, Allar has the tools to either soar or keep you wanting more.
1.08: GARRETT NUSSMEIER, QB LSU
The QB carousel keeps spinning with LSU’s Garrett Nussmeier coming off the board. With Arch, Nico, and LaNorris teasing eligibility but flirting with extra college time, Nussmeier—alongside Drew Allar—could snag the top QB crown if the trio stands pat.
Nuss has been slinging it in Baton Rouge, but his NFL stock hinges on a couple of questions: can his 6-foot-2, 200-pound frame survive the league, and can he tame his gunslinger style with another year of coaching?
Nussmeier has a cannon that makes scouts weak, but the SEC beatdowns he’s endured have folks questioning his durability, even though he’s shown immense toughness. Another year at LSU isn’t just about racking up stats; it’s for bulking up and improving his decision-making.
If he lands in a play-action, roll-out-happy NFL system, he’ll shine bright in the league. With proven chops against the SEC and a knack for dissecting complex defenses, Nussmeier has massive NFL upside.
1.09: MAKHI HUGHES, RB OREGON
In a transfer portal stampede that looked like a Black Friday sale, Makhi Hughes made a national statement by ditching Tulane for Will Stein’s high-octane offense, because who doesn’t want to upgrade to Eugene, especially when the NIL bag hits?
Stein’s already churned out fantasy darling Bucky Irving and future star Jordan James. Now, Hughes is waltzing into Eugene ready to feast in an attack that’s about to lean hard on its ground game with a TBD at QB.
Hughes was a Green Wave wrecking ball, piling up 2,779 rushing yards and 24 total touchdowns over two seasons, including a freshman breakout with over 1,300 yards. He’s a true workhorse oozing with RB1 experience, which should only help his jump to the B1G.
At 5’11” and 210 lbs, this three-down bruiser’s built like a tank with speed to kill, and this upcoming season is his golden ticket to the national stage. Dynasty managers, take note: Hughes’ stock is about to skyrocket. He’s got the chops to be Oregon’s next fantasy stud and maybe your 2026 first-round pick.
1.10: CARNELL TATE, WR OHIO STATE
Brian Hartline’s churning out another gem, and this time it’s Carnell Tate, the former five-star who played third fiddle to Ohio State’s alien overlord Jeremiah Smith and future first-rounder Emeka Egbuka.
Last season, Tate was the third wheel, but he still flashed enough sparkle to turn heads, like that seven-catch, 87-yard masterclass against Texas in the CFP semis. Now, with the WR2 gig next to Smith all to himself, Tate’s primed to explode with Hartline promoted to offensive coordinator.
The tape’s spilling secrets, and they’re all good: Tate can be an NFL chain-mover with a side of Chicago swagger. His route-running is slick, and he has a knack for snagging balls in traffic. At a lanky 6’3” with room to bulk up, he’s not the burner who’ll leave corners in the dust, but his crafty moves and body control scream future QB security blanket.
As he becomes more dynamic and fills out, Tate has the makings of a fantasy stud with reliable hands, clutch plays, and an early breakout in an offense that produces wideouts.
1.11: EVAN STEWART, WR OREGON
Evan Stewart, the five-star phenom who outshone Luther Burden III and Tetairoa McMillan as the No. 1 WR in his recruiting class, is stepping into the spotlight as Oregon’s WR1—and it’s do-or-die time. With Tez Johnson and Traeshon Holden bolting for the NFL draft, the Ducks’ passing game is Stewart’s to command.
This former high school track star has the kind of talent that makes scouts drool, but he’s been a tease. He flashes brilliance (like that 7-catch, 149-yard, 1-TD torching of Ohio State) while leaving us hungry for more consistency.
Stewart’s freshman breakout screamed star power with 53 grabs for 649 yards and two scores in 10 games, but last year’s 48-613-5 stat line didn’t quite pop—two big games don’t cut it when you’re this hyped.
Now, back for an encore as Oregon’s undisputed top dog, Stewart is at a crossroads. He can string together an elite season or risk fading into “what if” territory. The speed, the hands, the talent—it’s all there, begging to erupt.
1.12: CJ BAXTER, RB TEXAS
I will roll the dice and toss my last chip on a wild card: CJ Baxter, the former five-star running back with a juicy comeback story.
The No. 1 RB recruit of his class, Baxter hit the ground running as a true freshman in 2023, piling up nearly 700 yards and five touchdowns on just 138 carries, while splitting reps with Panthers RB Jonathan Brooks and NFL-bound Jaydon Blue.
Then a gruesome ACL and PCL tear in training camp sidelined him for all of 2024, letting Jaydon Blue hog the spotlight. But hold your horns—Baxter’s on the mend, strutting around brace-free and eyeing a full 2025 comeback.
He’ll form a committee with Tre Wisner (Longhorns’ 2024 leading rusher), so don’t sleep on this duo. With his pedigree, burst, and a chip on his shoulder, Baxter’s a dynasty target who could declare early after a monster season or stick around another one for a second-year post-ACL.
ELIGIBLE PLAYERS TO KEEP AN EYE ON
QUARTERBACKS: Cade Klubnik (Clemson), Sam Leavitt (ASU), Dante Moore (Oregon), Carson Beck (Miami), Haynes King (Georgia Tech), John Mateer (Oklahoma), Miller Moss (USC), Jalon Daniels (Kansas)
RUNNING BACKS: Justice Haynes (Michigan), Tre Wisner (Texas), Jaydn Ott (California), Kaytron Allen (Penn State), Darius Taylor (Minnesota), Le’Veon Moss (Texas A&M), Jonah Coleman (Washington), CJ Donaldson (Ohio State), Dylan Edwards (Kansas State), A’Marion Peterson (USC), Datrell Jones (Boston College), Jeremiah Cobb (Auburn), Mark Fletcher Jr. (Miami)
WIDE RECEIVERS: Antonio Williams (Clemson), Zachariah Branch (Georgia), Makai Lemon (USC), Nic Anderson (LSU), Germie Bernard (Alabama), Eugene Wilson (Florida), Johntay Cook (Texas), Kevin Concepcion (Texas A&M), Nyck Harbor (South Carolina), Eric Singleton Jr. (Georgia Tech), Denzel Boston (Washington), Jaden Greathouse (Notre Dame)
TIGHT ENDS: Trey Leckner (Washington State), Luke Hasz (Arkansas), Oscar Delp (Georgia), Shamar Easter (Arkansas), Max Klare (Ohio State)
